6 Comments

I watched your zoom meeting last night and found it to be very informative. I'd be interested in your opinion of long-time leftist critic Norman Finkelstein whose basic view of the Gaza situation can be seen here: https://courageouslion380.substack.com/p/here-is-what-we-are-not-being-told

Where Rabbi is he going wrong and does he make any valid points at all?

Expand full comment

Thanks for your question. I just watched one video so far. He is giving the Marxist Revolutionary talking points for one side of the phony dialectic. Each side uses some truth mixed with some incendiary falsehood to justify the conflict and warfare that squeezes everyone in the middle. So he the truth that he speaks is that the residents of Gaza are in a terrible situation. But he doesn’t tell you that it’s a combined effort of the Marxists of all flags to create that suffering, to use it as a ‘cause’ for warfare, and to use it as a recruitment ground for an army of terrorists. As you heard me say on Thursday night, the Gazans and everyone else in the Middle East must be liberated from all Marxists of all flags.

Expand full comment

You made the point I think on Thursday that it was the Marxists on the Israeli side that breached Israel's security by giving up Gaza. Did you also feel they were too harsh in Gaza before the giveaway engendering resentment and rage among the Palestinians? What about afterward?

Expand full comment

Just watched second video. As the advocate for just one side of the phony dialectic, he does not tell you that Amnesty International also issued a report about how Hamas murders Gazans to maintain its terror regime over the Arabs.

As I discussed on Thursday night, all the Israeli military moves in Gaza are completely unnecessary because they only result from having created a terror base in Gaza in the first place - a terror base that wars against Arab and Jew alike.

I don’t buy that the 2006 election was ‘honest’, Jimmy Carter’s claims otherwise. An ‘election’ was held so that the Hamas label of the Marxist revolutionaries could have a bad cop base.

Expand full comment

>>As I discussed on Thursday night, all the Israeli military moves in Gaza are completely unnecessary because they only result from having created a terror base in Gaza in the first place - a terror base that wars against Arab and Jew alike<<

Do you mean the Israeli military moves WOULD HAVE BEEN unnecessary had an the appeasing Israeli government not given Gaza back to Hamas in 2006? If so, what should Israel do now?

Expand full comment

Rabbi here is another video I would love for you to comment on. https://faiezkirsten.substack.com/p/the-mystery-of-israel-solved

Was there any chance the intelligence failure was intentional as this commentator suggests?

Expand full comment